When Kellie Pickler was a contestant on American Idol, she chose to perform "Suds in the Bucket" by Sara Evans as a Top 10 finalist in the contest. It didn't go so well.
All three judges thought she was "better than that song". It was a rough night for her.
Simon Cowell was probably the hardest on her (as was his nature). He said, "There are thousands and thousands of songs to choose from, and you choose some gimmicky, rodeo, lassoing, whatever novelty song."
Kellie made it to the Top 6 before being eliminated.
Check out the performance here: